How to write the community, identity, and background essay after the affirmative action ruling

How to write the community, identity, and background essay after the affirmative action ruling

September 23, 2026

By Nicholas Chung


Harvard asks how the life experiences that shaped you will let you contribute. Vanderbilt asks how your identity, culture, or background played a role in your growth. Brown asks how an aspect of your growing up inspired or challenged you. Rice asks what perspectives shaped by your background inspire you to join its community of change agents. Johns Hopkins asks what you have learned about engaging across differences. Dartmouth asks how difference has been part of your life.

Six colleges, six word counts, one question.

It is the most common supplemental prompt in selective admissions right now, and the one applicants handle worst. The wording is also new, at nearly every school, and it changed for a specific reason. Understanding that reason is most of the work, because it tells you exactly what the prompt is measuring and what it quietly refuses to reward.


The same question, six ways

CollegeThe promptLimit
Harvard"Harvard has long recognized the importance of enrolling a student body with a diversity of perspectives and experiences. How will the life experiences that shaped who you are today enable you to contribute to Harvard?"150 words
Brown"Share how an aspect of your growing up has inspired or challenged you, and what unique contributions this might allow you to make to the Brown community."150 to 250 words
Vanderbilt"Vanderbilt University's motto, Crescere aude, is Latin for 'dare to grow.' In your response, reflect on how one or more aspects of your identity, culture, or background has played a role in your personal growth, and how it will contribute to our campus community as you dare to grow at Vanderbilt."250 words
Dartmouth"How has difference been a part of your life, and how have you embraced it as part of your identity, outlook, or sense of purpose?" (offered as one option among several)250 words
Johns Hopkins"Drawing on your own experiences, what have you learned about engaging across differences and how has it shaped the way you think about building bridges, enhancing community, and working with others?"350 words
Rice"Rice is strengthened by its diverse community of learning and discovery that produces leaders and change agents across the spectrum of human endeavor. What perspectives shaped by your background, experiences, upbringing, and/or cultural identity inspire you to join our community of change agents at Rice?"500 words

Read the verbs before you write anything. Harvard wants your experiences to enable a contribution. Brown wants an aspect of growing up that inspired or challenged you. Hopkins wants what you learned, which means the essay has to contain a change of mind. Dartmouth wants to know how you embraced difference. Rice wants perspectives that inspire you to join a specific kind of community.

Not one of them asks who you are. Every one of them asks what happened as a result.


Why the prompts are worded this way

In June 2023, the Supreme Court ruled in Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College that the race-conscious admissions programs at Harvard and the University of North Carolina violated the Equal Protection Clause. That much most applicants know.

What matters for your essay is the paragraph near the end of the majority opinion. Chief Justice Roberts wrote that "nothing in this opinion should be construed as prohibiting universities from considering an applicant's discussion of how race affected his or her life, be it through discrimination, inspiration, or otherwise." He then set the condition. A benefit to a student who overcame racial discrimination "must be tied to that student's courage and determination." A benefit to a student whose heritage or culture motivated a leadership role "must be tied to that student's unique ability to contribute to the university." And then the sentence every admissions office spent the following summer reading: the student "must be treated based on his or her experiences as an individual," not on the basis of race.

Within one application cycle, the supplements at selective colleges were rewritten. Brown replaced a prior essay prompt and added four short-answer questions for the first class it admitted after the ruling, and described the decision as one factor among several in the change. You can see the result in the wording above: none of the six prompts asks what group you belong to, and all six ask what that belonging produced.

This post takes no position on the ruling. The practical consequence is what you need, and it is narrow. The prompts now ask about effect, not membership. An essay that names a category has answered a question nobody asked.


Name the effect, not the category

Here is the same student, twice.

Instead of: "As a first-generation Vietnamese American, I have a unique perspective that has shaped who I am. Growing up between two cultures taught me the value of diversity and made me more open-minded."

Try: "I have been my family's translator since I was eleven. I have sat through a mortgage refinancing, two parent-teacher conferences held about my younger brother, and one appointment where I had to learn the word for arrhythmia in both languages in about four minutes. You develop a particular skill doing this: you learn to watch the face of the person who is not talking."

Same student. Same background. The first version stops at the category and then reports a feeling about it. The second names what the background caused: a responsibility carried since age eleven, a vocabulary built under pressure, a specific habit of attention that now belongs to the writer in every room they enter.

That is the whole technical lesson, and it applies no matter what you are writing about. Ask what your background made you do, know, notice, or carry. Then write that.

A useful test: cross out every sentence that would still be true if you had the same background but had done nothing with it. Most weak drafts lose 70 percent of their words to that pen. What survives is the essay.


If you think you have nothing to write

This is the largest group of readers, and most guides skip you. So, plainly: "background" is not a synonym for hardship, and it is not a synonym for minority status.

It is where you come from and what that did to you. The list of things that qualify is much longer than applicants assume:

  • Your family's work. A parent who farms, drives nights, runs a salon, or teaches at the school you attend.
  • Your town's economy. A mill that closed, a base that opened, a tourist season that owns four months of your year.
  • A subculture you actually live in. Competitive marching band, rodeo, robotics, church youth group, restaurant kitchens, online communities where you moderate something.
  • Being the only one. The only person in your family who codes, or reads music, or is going to college at all.
  • A practice or a discipline. A religious observance, a training schedule, a language spoken only at home.
  • A change you did not choose. An illness in the family, a divorce, a move, a job you took because the household needed it.

Then run the generative exercise, which is a single question: what did you have to learn that your friends did not have to learn?

Answer it in a list, fast, without editing. Real answers from real drafts look like this: how to read a Friday night ticket rail in a restaurant kitchen. How to tell from a phone call's first three seconds whether it is a bill collector. How to find the cheapest flight to visit a grandparent, and how to explain to a teacher why you will miss the test. How to ask a doctor a follow-up question. How to be the person who explains the rules of American high school to a cousin who just arrived.

Every one of those is an essay. None of them is a tragedy, and none of them requires you to claim an identity you do not have.


Writing about something hard without performing it

If your material is genuinely painful, the risk in this prompt is real. Trauma is not currency. An essay that stages suffering for an audience reads badly, and it costs the writer something to produce.

Four rules keep you on the right side of it.

  • Write from distance, not from inside it. If you cannot yet describe the event in ordinary sentences, it is too soon, and there is no obligation to use it. Pick other material.
  • Give the reader enough detail to understand, and stop. One concrete specific does more than a paragraph of intensity. The reader does not need the worst night. They need to know what the year required of you.
  • Keep control of the frame. You decide what is on the page. An admissions reader is not owed your medical history, your family's finances, or the details of anyone else's crisis.
  • Land in the present. The reader's real question is always what you do now. An essay that ends in the hardest moment has answered half the prompt.

If a hard experience belongs in your application as context rather than as a story, it may not belong in this essay at all. The Additional Information section on the Common App exists precisely for facts a reader needs without narrative around them.


The contribution half, where drafts collapse

Five of the six prompts above ask what you will bring. Almost every draft answers with a promise.

Instead of: "I will bring my unique perspective to campus discussions and contribute to the diverse community at Vanderbilt."

Try: "I run the shop alone on Sundays, which mostly means deciding which of two unhappy people gets talked to first. I have gotten good at the version of that problem where nobody is wrong."

The substitution is mechanical once you see it: describe what you already do, in specific terms, and let the reader infer that you will keep doing it. A promise is unverifiable and every applicant makes the same one. A habit is evidence, and evidence is the only thing in an application a reader can act on.

Two more things about the contribution half:

  • Do not name campus organizations you have not joined. "I will join the Vietnamese Students Association" is a plan, not a contribution, and it tells the reader nothing they did not already know about their own campus.
  • Keep it proportional. At 150 words, contribution is your last sentence. At 500, it is your last paragraph. It never takes more than a quarter of the essay, because what you did is more persuasive than what you predict.

Rice's own admission office puts the standard plainly in its advice to applicants: readers want insight into "your interests, background and perspective through your eyes." Through your eyes, not through a description of the campus.


The same material at 150, 250, and 500 words

You will write this essay five or six times at different lengths. Do not write five essays. Write the material once, then cut to fit, and understand that each length is a different shape rather than the same shape trimmed.

150 words (Harvard). One scene, one consequence, one present-tense habit. There is no room for setup, so open inside the specific: the appointment, the shift, the kitchen. Roughly four to six sentences total, with the contribution as the last one.

250 words (Vanderbilt, Dartmouth, and the upper end of Brown). Now you can afford a second instance, which is what turns an anecdote into a pattern. Note that Vanderbilt asks about growth and contribution, so the middle of the essay needs an actual change in you, not just a repeated circumstance.

350 words (Johns Hopkins). Hopkins asks what you learned, so this version needs a complication: a moment the thing you believed did not hold. Budget about a third of the words for the situation, a third for the friction, and a third for what you do differently now.

500 words (Rice). The only length where a full arc fits. Resist using it on more backstory. Spend the extra 250 words on the present, on the specifics of what you now do, and on the part of Rice's community you are actually equipped to join.

The rule underneath all four: as the word count falls, cut the past first. Origin material is the most compressible thing in the essay, and the most replaceable. Our guide to mastering supplemental essays covers the adaptation problem in general, and the same discipline that solves the why this major essay once and reuses it everywhere applies here.


What not to do

  • No dictionary definitions. Not diversity, not community, not identity. The reader works in admissions and knows the words.
  • No service trip abroad. The essay about a week spent building something in a country you had not previously thought about is the single most recognizable submission in the pile.
  • Do not claim an identity that is not yours. It reads false, and the people reading have seen the real version thousands of times.
  • Do not make open-mindedness your thesis. "I learned to see other perspectives" is the conclusion of nearly every draft, which is exactly why it persuades nobody.
  • Do not reuse a school's own marketing language back at it. Rice's "change agents" and Vanderbilt's Crescere aude are in the prompt to give you a frame, not a phrase to quote.
  • Do not write the same essay for a school with a separate community prompt. If you are also writing UC Personal Insight Question 7, keep the material distinct.

Run this on your finished draft

Five questions. Any "no" is a rewrite.

  • Does something happen in the first two sentences? Not a claim about yourself. An event, a place, a task.
  • Could a reader state what your background caused, in one sentence, after reading? If the answer is "they learned to appreciate their culture," you are still at the category.
  • Is there a verb in the present tense? Something you still do. This is the sentence the contribution half rests on.
  • Would this essay collapse if you removed the identity label? It should not. The label is context, and the behavior is the argument.
  • Is there one sentence only you could have written? One is enough. If you cannot find it, go back to the question about what you had to learn.

The prompts changed because the law changed, but the thing they are testing was always the thing worth writing. Not what you are. What you carried, what it cost, what you got good at, and what you will keep doing next year in a place where nobody yet knows any of it. Write that down in specifics, and the 150-word version and the 500-word version will both be strong, because they are drawing on the same real material.

Nicholas Chung

Nicholas Chung

Founder & Head Counselor

10 years. 100+ students. Nicholas built Uni to put that same guidance in every applicant's hands and help them earn that acceptance letter.